Lugos and Gaulish Mercury

The Irish god Lugh, we’re told, is one version of a pan-Celtic deity, called Llew in Wales and Lugos/Lugus in Gaul. Given that Lugh was such an important deity, and that Lugos could be the Celtic Mercury that Julius Caesar describes, you would expect Lugos to also be an important and well-attested god.

So it’s a bit of a shock to look up the Gaulish god Lugos/Lugos on the Epigraphik Datenbank and find no inscriptions matching his name. Why is Lugos so often assumed to be the Gaulish Mercury when there’s very little evidence for his worship in France?

We know that scholars didn’t invent a cult of Lugos for fun, so what led them to suppose that the cult of Lugh and Llew extended to continental Europe? (And no, there are no inscriptions for Lugh in England or Scotland either.) A lot of it is based on inference, since the lack of inscriptions has led scholars to use indirect evidence to support their theory. It’s a good reminder of how little evidence we have to work with, and how much rests on interpretation.

Given the lack of archaeolgical evidence, the argument for a Lugos-cult rests on three pillars:

  1. Julius Caesar’s description of the “Gaulish Mercury”.
  2. Place-names: Lugdunum et al.
  3. August 1st festival at Lyons.

Gaulish Mercury

Julius Caesar famously said that Mercury was the most important of the Gaulish gods, although in arrogant Roman fashion he neglected to give local names for the deities he was describing. His description of this god is intriguing, both for what it mentions and what it leaves out:

They worship as their divinity, Mercury in particular, and have many images of him, and regard him as the inventor of all arts, they consider him the guide of their journeys and marches, and believe him to have great influence over the acquisition of gain and mercantile transactions.
(Julius Caesar, De Bello Gallico VI.17.1)

You’ll notice he doesn’t mention Mercury’s role as psychopomp, but he does emphasize Mercury’s role as patron of travelers and merchants. The Roman Mercury, however, was not the founder of the arts, although one story tells how he invented the lyre to appease his older brother Apollo’s wrath.

Statue of Hermes (Mercury) with his attributes. Wikimedia.

There are many inscriptions to Deo Mercurio throughout France, and Mercury often appears alongside the goddess Rosmerta in inscriptions and art. (They share attributes, too. She sometimes holds his purse or caduceus – his snake-entwined staff.) He also appears alongside the horned god Cernunnos. It is hard to know how many of these are hiding a local deity.

We do know that there are a number of Gaulish gods who were associated with Mercury. In northern Gaul (Belgica) there were Visucius, Gebrinus and Cissonius, who seem to have had cults of their own, since occasionally they appear as deo Visucius/Cissonius on inscriptions. Many local gods many be hiding under the practice of invoking the Mercury of [place name], such as Mercurio Arvenorix, Dumias, and Vosegus. (And then there’s the question of Esus and Teutates, also candidates for Mercury.)

There seems little here to connect Lugh to the Gaulish Mercury, except for the claim to be “inventor of all the arts”. Lugh’s calling card was his mastery of all arts and trades, which earned him a place in the councils of the Tuatha de Danann. But there seems no reason to connect Lugh with a Gaulish god when there are a number of Mercuries nearby. This is where point no. 2 comes in.

The St. John Wharf in Lyons, with the basilica in the background. Pixabay.

The strongholds of Lugh

The French city of Lyons was called Lugdunum in Roman times, which could be read as “the fortress of Lugh”. Other place-names with the Lug– element include Laon, Leiden, Loudon, Liegnitz, Léon, Dinlleu, and Carlisle (Luguvalium). (MacKillop: 310) This would seem to impressive evidence for a widespread cult of Lugh.

However, there had to be a push-back.The Celtic scholar Bernard Maier, who inspired this post, questioned the connection between Lugh and Lyons. For a start, he points out that the etymology of the name “lug” is still not certain, so we don’t know if these towns were named for the god, or possibly something like the “warrior fortress” (lug = lynx = warrior) like the towns of Cinegotrix and possibly Cunorix. (John Koch casts doubt on this, too, but the name Lugh could also be traced back to words meaning light, vow, or raven, giving several possible meanings.)

Scholars who support the Lyons as stronghold of Lugh theory point to the names Camulodunum and Carrodunum, which could point to the gods Camulos and some other god, although Carrodunum can also be translated as “chariot-fortress, and Camulos could be someone’s name as well as a god’s. Despite its promising name, Carlisle was named for a person, probably an Iron Age noble, named Luguvalos.

Maier raises one important point, though. In the towns supposedly named for Lugh and Camulos, there is not one altar, not one item inscribed with the names of their patron deities. By contrast, the town of Aquileia, whose patron was the healing god Belenus, had 20+ dedications to its patron god. (Maier: 129) (The Epigraphik Datenbank makes it 39.)

Lughnasa in France?

Point no. 3 is that Lugh’s festival was August 1st, the great Irish harvest festival called Lughnasa, honouring the god and his foster-mother Tailtiu. Augustus Caesar, or Octavian, declared a yearly festival in Lyons/Lugdunum on August 1st, which some scholars assume recognized a local Lughnasa-like festival already in existence.

This may be true, although I don’t think there’s any record of a festival before Octavian declared one. Octavian had his own reasons to remember August the first, since he won the Battle of Alexandria on that day, defeating Mark Antony and Cleopatra. He had lost the first battle on July 31st, but regrouped and won a decisive victory.

Antony and Cleopatra then committed suicide, leaving Octavian as ruler of the Roman Empire, with a rich new province, Egypt. You can see how he might think this was a more important occasion to remember.

Votive inscription to Lugus. Lugo, Galicia.

Switzerland and Spain – the Lugoves

The name Lugoves is, as you might guess from the form, plural. It’s not clear whether these deities were supposed to be a multiple form of a Lugh-like deity, or some other form of deity who shares the lug– element in his/her/their name. Maier points out that they could even be goddesses, which suggests some form of the matres (mother-goddesses) to me.

The Swiss dedication is both straightforward and enigmatic: it is simply the word Lvgoves carved into the top of a decorated pillar. It’s clearly not graffiti, but who put it there and why is unknown.

Several of the Spanish dedications cluster in the north-east of the country, at Sober, Panton and Otero del Rey (Lugo). The forms (Lucubo Arquienobo, Locoubu Arquienis) probably derive from the personal name Arquius. Another, from Osma (Uxama Argaela), on the other side of the country, was dedicated by the cobblers’ guild.

Interestingly, yet another inscription is undoubtedly to goddesses, a votive altar that reads:

Lugun[i]s / deabus / Aur(elius) · Cel(er) · / vot(um) · s(olvit) · l(ibens) · m(erito)

But there is a singular male form, from Peñalba de Villastar, although the inscription itself still resists a full reading. But it does seem to have the word Luguei, “to Lugus”, which would make it an inscription to the singular god. (For some interpretations of the inscription, see here.) The sole French inscription, from Nîmes, is to a deity named in the singular male: Lucubus. It reads:

Rufina Lucubus votum solvit libens merito. (CIL 12, 3080)

so she was fulfilling a vow to the god by commissioning it, but was Lucubus the same god as the Spanish Locoubu Arquienis?

It’s hard to know what to make of it all. It might seem that Lugus/Lugoves is another case like that of Veteres/Vitiris in northern England, whose name appears in both genders, plural and singular. Clearly the situation in Spain was far more fluid than we tidy-minded moderns would like it to be.

Cursing Tablets and Lugh

Among the proofs of Lugos’ existence in France you sometimes see listed a cursing tablet from Chamalières in France, which has the words luge dessummiíis repeated three times. The text is very hard to understand to begin with, and it’s not clear what luge dessummiíis actually means.

One interpretation was “I prepare them for Lugus” but others favour legal meanings, like “May you… to my right” (Lambert) or “I prepare them for committing” (Mees: Loc. 648) It’s hard to make definite statements about something that allows so many interpretations.

Conclusion

So it would seem that it is easier to find a cult of Lugh in Spain than France! This isn’t the result I was expecting when I began this article, but it’s inevitable. As I said above, a lot of the evidence for Lugos isn’t so much evidence as a way of reading certain data, which could just as easily be read in other ways.

After the discovery of a new British goddess ten years ago, I wouldn’t be too quick to write off Gaulish Lugos. The dedication from Nîmes tells us that a god named Lucubus had at least one worshipper, and time may reveal more. After all, I’ve written whole posts about deities who had only one or two inscriptions to prove they ever existed. But I still feel a bit let down that the major cult of Lugos, with inscriptions and other physical proof, might not exist.

Having said this, many intelligent and learned people find the argument for a cult of Lugos convincing, and a lot does depend on how you read the evidence. For my part, though, I can’t help but feel that people felt that there ought to be a cult of a Lug-like god to be the Gaulish Mercury, and cut their cloth to fit that pattern, while attested Mercury-gods like Cissonius seem to have been ignored.


References and Links
Adkins, Lesley and Roy A. Adkins 1996: Dictionary of Roman Religion, OUP.
Arenas-Esteban, J. Alberto and Raúl Lopez-Romero 2010: “Celtic Divine Names in the Iberian Pennisula: towards a territorial analysis,” Celtic Religion Across Space and Time, ed. J. Alberto Arenas-Esteban, Junta de Comunicadades de Castilla-La Mancha: 242-57. (academica.edu)
Green, Miranda 1997: Dictonary of Celtic Myth and Legend, Thames and Hudson.
MacKillop, James 2004: An Oxford Dictionary of Celtic Mythology, OUP.
Maier, Bernhardt 1996: “Is Lug to be Identified with Mercury? (Bell. Gall. VI.17.1)? New Suggestions on an Old Problem,” Ériu XLVII: 127-35.
Ovist, Krista 2004: The Integration of Mercury and Lugus: Myth and History in Late Iron Age and Early Roman Gaul, University of Chicago, diss.
Pedreño, J. Olivares 2005: “Celtic Gods of the Iberian Pennisula,” e-Keltoi 6: 607-49. (academia.edu)

Wikipedia article on Lugus
Deo Mercurio – Au dieu Mercure (in French)
Polytheist.com on Lugus (for the other side of the argument)
Lugus Explained

For the source of the image at the top, click here.

5 thoughts on “Lugos and Gaulish Mercury

  1. Pingback: Lugos and Gaulish Mercury — We Are Star Stuff | Die Goldene Landschaft

  2. Gullveig Press

    There’s A LOT of papers out now on Lug in Iberia. He’s written in Phoenician script, thanked in the furthest southwest part of Portugal from the 6th century BCE so He seems to be an Atlantic Celtic seacoast deity. The papers coming out right now have a lot more information than the books and online encyclopedias, so many Pagans are working with old out of date information.

    Southern Gaul adopted Hermes from Greece, which I think helped in their acceptance of Mercury. Also Gaulish merchants probably paid for Mercury shrines, brought them to their villages or cities, and created a Gaulish interpretation of Mercury. Indigenous interpretation of Roman religion shows how it was a two way street. The Gaulish Mercury probably meant something different to the Gauls via their needs and whomever told them about the religion of Rome, and what they understood about their God Hermes, who has similar symbolism.

    As most of the Gaulish inscriptions come from the Roman era, and the Romans had already killed the Druid elite, it’s possible that Lugos was a popular earlier deity of the Gauls. There’d be no written records of Him. It’s like how few British deities we know – .most inscriptions are to the deities of the Celtic .military in the Roman Empire. Meanwhile there are sacred areas of the Britons with no written evidence to tell us who these deities are.

    As the Celtiberian region is next to Gaul and Lugus is popular there, He was not just on the coast and islands. I believe that He was just earlier than the Roman Era and in Gaul His worship may have changed or simply ended,to continue in Iberia and Ireland and the British islands that traded with Iberia – Unless the Mabinogi is heavily influenced by the nearby Irish who raided and settled.Wales, and Llew is based on Lugh – the shoe maker Iberia – Mabinogi link may show a connection between the regions.

    The 6th century BCE is when the Celtic sea trade splits in half, with Iberia now involved more with the Mediterranean culture and trade, so Lug seems to predate that.

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply
    1. solsdottir Post author

      Yes, the Iberian stuff is really interesting – that was the best part of researching what could have been merely a spoilsport post.
      The trade connections between Spain, Ireland and Wales make it likely that they could share religious ideas as well.

      I like your idea that Lugh is a deity of the Celtic sea-coasts, considering Barry Cunliffe’s ideas about communication and trade along the Western Atlantic coastline.

      Like

      Reply
  3. Pingback: Apollo, Odin and Lugh | We Are Star Stuff

  4. Pingback: Celtic Mercuries | We Are Star Stuff

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.